# Balthasar & Speyr Catalogue (io.github.balthasarspeyr/catalogue): tool descriptions scored - tools/list taken: 2026-11-02 (UTC) - From: [Official MCP Registry](https://registry.modelcontextprotocol.io/v0/servers/io.github.balthasarspeyr%2Fcatalogue/versions/latest) - Connected to: https://mcp.balthasarspeyr.org/mcp - Homepage: https://balthasarspeyr.org/en/artificial-intelligence - Scoring rules: v2 - Tools: 22 - Average: 39.5 / 100 (Rain) - Near-identical pairs: 1 This page shows how Balthasar & Speyr Catalogue (io.github.balthasarspeyr/catalogue)'s tool descriptions scored, the issues found and the names of its tools and parameters. The descriptions are the server's own: read them where the copy came from. Forecall asked the URL this server lists in the official MCP Registry for its tools/list once, on the date above, without calling any tool. The server may have changed since. ## Across the server - Minor: The server's instructions are 4075 characters. Claude Code reads only the first 2,048 by default (Codex 0.154.0 reads them whole). Put what the server is for first. ## Tools - `count_catalog`: 31 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_topic_evidence`: 31 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `list_journals`: 31 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The description mentions none of its 3 or more arguments. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `list_works`: 31 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize, facets, sortBy, sortOrder. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument facets is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_bibliography_source`: 34 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: page, pageSize. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_corpus_coverage`: 34 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_download_links`: 34 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: publicationId, checkAvailability. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument checkAvailability is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - Minor: Required identifiers whose description does not say where the value comes from: publicationId. Name the tool or the place that returns it, or models look it up first. - `get_publications`: 34 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize, facets, sortBy, sortOrder. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument facets is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `list_publications`: 34 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize, facets, sortBy, sortOrder. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument facets is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_publication_text`: 37 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: publicationId, offset, limit. - Minor: The description mentions none of its 3 or more arguments. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - Minor: Required identifiers whose description does not say where the value comes from: publicationId. Name the tool or the place that returns it, or models look it up first. - `get_work`: 37 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: workId. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - Minor: Required identifiers whose description does not say where the value comes from: workId. Name the tool or the place that returns it, or models look it up first. - `search_life_mission_and_community`: 37 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: question, subjects, topics, offset, pageSize. - Minor: The description mentions none of its 3 or more arguments. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `search_works`: 40 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: query, filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, limit, lexicalQueries, lexicalQueries[].language, lexicalQueries[].text. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_common_life_and_mission`: 41 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: topic. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - `get_community_of_saint_john`: 41 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: topic. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - `aggregate_catalog`: 42 / 100 - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize, periodYears, groupBy. - Minor: The description mentions none of its 3 or more arguments. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_topics_by_period`: 42 / 100 - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, offset, page, pageSize, interval, periods, periods[].from, periods[].to, firstYears. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_person_life_and_mission`: 44 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: person, topic. - `export_bibliography`: 47 / 100 - Major: Arguments without a description: filters, filters.authorIds, filters.workIds, filters.publicationIds, filters.baselReferences, filters.baselReferencePrefix, filters.journalIds, filters.journalScope, filters.topicIds, filters.includeSemantic, filters.title, filters.reference, filters.workTypes, filters.publicationTypes, filters.originalYearFrom, filters.originalYearTo, filters.publicationYearFrom, filters.publicationYearTo, filters.originalLanguages, filters.publicationLanguages, filters.inOriginalLanguage, filters.labelIds, filters.publisherIds, filters.translatorIds, filters.downloadFormats, filters.hasDownload, filters.hasExtractedText, filters.isIndexed, filters.full, recordType, offset, pageSize, includeInline. - Minor: No `required` list, so every argument is optional. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.includeSemantic is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.inOriginalLanguage is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasDownload is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.hasExtractedText is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.isIndexed is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument filters.full is unclear. - Minor: The meaning of the boolean argument includeInline is unclear. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `search_publication_text`: 47 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Major: Arguments without a description: publicationId, query, offset, limit. - Minor: The description mentions none of its 3 or more arguments. - Minor: Required identifiers whose description does not say where the value comes from: publicationId. Name the tool or the place that returns it, or models look it up first. - `get_catalog_options`: 52 / 100 - Major: Says nothing about when to use it, or when not to. - Minor: Says nothing about what it returns. - `get_vocation_discernment_contact`: 69 / 100 Is your server listed here and you would rather it were not? Email support@forecall.dev, and we will take it off within 7 days. [All scored servers](https://forecall.dev/en/servers)